Is Christian Nationalism America’s True Roots?

When the Roots Still Remember

Whenever people argue about whether America is… or ever was… a Christian nation, it helps to slow down a bit and look at the soil this country grew from. Dig deep enough, and you’ll find its roots tangled in Puritan faith, watered by sacrifice, and fed by the belief that government began not in marble halls but in a man’s own heart.

Today, we often use the term’ faith’ as a mere campaign slogan. However, a calm stroll through history reveals a different narrative… one where character held more weight than constitutions, and where faith was the guiding force behind freedom, not the other way around.

The historical significance of Christian faith in shaping America’s laws and morals is a testament to its enduring influence.

Puritanism: The Wild Vine That Never Died

Let’s set the record straight: Puritanism didn’t just sprout in the frozen soil of New England. It spread like wildfire through the colonies, leaping borders and seeding communities from Massachusetts to Virginia.

It wasn’t just religion—it was a cultural force shaping laws, families, and the moral compass of a people determined to live under God’s authority rather than man’s.

Patrick Henry, the thunderbolt behind the famous ‘Give me liberty or give me death’ declaration, was a man of unwavering faith. He carried Christian classics in his saddlebag and distributed them to judges like gospel tracts. His parting words to his children were not about material wealth, but about the wealth of faith.

He prayed that America would continue to uphold God’s Word as her cornerstone, a testament to his deep-rooted faith in both his personal and professional life.

The Faith That Lit the Founders

We’re often told the Founders were mere Deists, distant from devotion. But the evidence says otherwise. George Washington guarded the Sabbath like a sentinel.

He expected his soldiers to honor it too—any man caught cursing God faced forty lashes. Harsh? Maybe. But Washington knew that victory required more than muscle…  it required moral discipline, a clean conscience, and Heaven’s favor.

To him, faith wasn’t an accessory to liberty… it was liberty’s foundation. Without it, freedom would collapse under the weight of its own pride.

What “Government” Once Meant

Say “government” today, and people picture domes, gavels, and microphones. But early Americans saw it differently. To them, government started where a man met his Maker… in the mirror. From there, it spread to family, church, and community, and only then to the civil magistrate.

Even taxes mirrored that order. Civil government was light and local; the real work of education, charity, and care for the poor flowed through the tithe. When immigrants landed at Salem, they weren’t met by bureaucrats with clipboards, but by Christian believers with open arms… offering shelter, lessons, and schools, all funded by faith, not bureaucracy and taxes.

When Tithing Held the World Together

Across the frontier, small towns lived out the gospel in motion. No orphan went unclaimed. No elder was left unloved. Neighbors carried each other’s burdens without waiting for permission from a welfare office. Charity wasn’t policy… it was a sacred duty.

Compare that to today’s red-tape jungles, where compassion is strangled by bureaucracy. Once upon a time, Christian homes like Captain Dollar’s Home for Boys in California sent young men into the world with nothing but a silver dollar, a handshake, and a moral compass pointing true north.

Wherever real charity thrives, the state loses its grip. That’s why in totalitarian systems, even helping a neighbor could be called “counter-revolutionary” and was severely punished. This was especially true in Soviet communism. The truth is that real compassion breeds freedom, and free men are hard to control.

The Bible Beneath the Bench

Early America’s laws were unapologetically biblical. Taking an oath wasn’t just a ceremony… it was a covenant. A promise with consequences. Juries once kept open Bibles as they deliberated. Judges saw themselves as “guardians of the covenant.” Harvard Law taught this well into the 1830s, when law students debated Leviticus without blushing.

The Founders didn’t fear faith; on the contrary, they feared the potential abuse of power when government interferes with religious matters. This fear is what led to the establishment of the First Amendment, not to eliminate faith from public life, but to prevent the Federal government from interfering with or dictating religious beliefs.

They had witnessed the suppression of preachers by Arminian bishops in England and wanted to ensure that America’s clergy had the freedom to preach truth from the pulpit, even when it challenged the powerful.

Every Law Has a Faith Behind It

Here’s a truth sharp enough to carve a blunt stone: every law grows from a moral seed, and every moral seed springs from a faith. You can’t separate them. Whether it’s Christianity or humanism, every legal system reveals its god.

Modern America has swapped one altar for another. Where schools were once built on Scripture, they now kneel before secular humanism… what Robert Kennedy once acknowledged as “a religious establishment of its own.” Again, the First Amendment was meant to protect faith from government… not to erase it from public life.

When Christian Law Was Tested

When Mormons defended polygamy as divine duty, the Supreme Court drew the line. Faith, the justices said, can never justify what moral law forbids. They weren’t endorsing one denomination… they were recognizing the soil from which the nation grew: a biblical moral order that formed the backbone of the Republic.

The War for America’s Soul

The Civil War spilled more than blood… it spilled belief. Historian Otto Scott argued that radicals in New England used John Brown’s violence to wrench America from its Christian moorings.

Other nations ended slavery by persuasion; America did it through cannon fire… and in doing so, shifted power from pulpit to Capitol. New taxes and public schools replaced tithes and church instruction. Slowly, the light of Scripture dimmed beneath the shadow of the state.

The Civil War was a turning point in America’s history, where the struggle to maintain a faith-based society was tested and ultimately altered by the forces of change.

A False Choice: Nationalism vs. Internationalism

It’s here that many conservatives stumble. In their longing for order, they rush to defend nationalism as the antidote to globalism. But that’s really a false choice. Choosing between nationalism and internationalism is like deciding between national socialism and international socialism in World War II. The correct answer is, “A plague on both your houses.”

Nationalism exalts the nation above God; internationalism bows to the dream of a global state. In the end, both are forms of statism, two idols of the same kind… one painted in stars and stripes, the other draped in the flag of humanity. Both forget that nations exist under God’s authority, not above it.

A Higher Allegiance

The believer’s loyalty can’t be confined by borders or treaties. His allegiance runs higher than any flag and deeper than any constitution. His fellowship spans nations… not politically, but spiritually… bound by faith, not government.

That’s why true “Christian Nationalism” isn’t about waving a banner… it’s about kneeling before the same Lord who made all nations. The original American idea wasn’t to worship the state or nation but to keep it small… restrained by the sovereignty of God and the self-government of the soul.

The Way Home

So where does that leave us? The path back isn’t hidden away somewhere… it’s the same one our forebears walked. Washington warned that if America abandoned faith and self-government, she’d rot from within. Renewal won’t come from politics, press conferences or think tanks. It’ll start around kitchen tables, in small churches, and in neighbors helping each other instead of government agencies going beyond their jurisdictions.

America was built by men and women who ruled themselves before they ruled others. They believed that strong families and giving hearts could build a nation without red tape or royal decree. Their diaries and sermons aren’t relics… they’re roadmaps to rebirth.

If America remembers that again, we might rediscover our most potent reflection… not a nation worshiping a nation, but a people walking humbly under God. If anything, Christian Nationalism is a byproduct of something much richer. So let’s not chase the byproduct lest we be “fooled again” as the Who sang about a while back. Let’s remember and embrace the essence.

Source: https://www.offthegridnews.com/religion/is-christian-nationalism-americas-true-roots/