Terror in Talcott---Poltergeists and Klan Rallies at the Old Manning Home

M.A. Manning From History of Summers County, by James Miller Accessed via Internet Archive

Back in April of 1925, the Hinton Daily News ran an interesting story about a haunted house in nearby Talcott, WV. The house in question was being rented to Mr. and Mrs. Paul Chattin, a young couple who had been married a little over a year. Shortly after moving in, the couple noticed an alarming display of poltergeist activity when their (presumably) heavy dresser turned itself completely around without the aid of human (living human, anyways) hands. At first, they sort of played the incident off and replaced the dresser to its normal position.

But it happened again.

The second time the dresser spun around on its own was the catalyst the Chattins needed. This time, they arose and fled in fear. At first, Paul had the upper hand and was in the lead toward the door. However, his wife Mabel, described as being fleet-footed, quickly flew past her husband. In the confusion, Paul saw a white-clad figure zoom past him and assumed it was the ghost, causing a second burst of panic. 

Needless to say, the Chattins moved out and did not return to their haunted home. The home in question, located at the upper edge of Talcott, was known locally as the Manning House. It once belonged to Matthew A. Manning and his family. 

Manning was born on May 4, 1848, in Ireland, but came to the United States at four years old. His family lived in Monroe County before moving to Nicholas County before the start of the Civil War. While living in Nicholas, Manning joined the Confederate Army. By 1871, he had moved to Talcott. Although he was a lawyer by profession, he took advantage of the population boom occurring as a result of the building of the C&O Railroad line and opened up a mercantile business with a man named Park. In 1876 he married Miss Mary Campbell. Together they had two surviving children, Frank and Faye. Sometime along the way, he built what would be known for years as the Manning House.

Manning was a prominent and (mostly) well-liked citizen. He was a Mason, a Catholic, and a politician. As a Democrat, he served multiple offices and even served on the Board of Education, as well as a stint as postmaster. Manning passed away in his home on December 13, 1900, from heart disease. 

Mary would live until 1926, but at some point had moved out of the home. She passed away at her daughter’s home in St. Albans, but her remains were said to have been brought home to the old Manning home and buried in Talcott Cemetery #2 alongside her husband. 

View of Talcott from Big Bend Mountain Source: WV History on View

For much of the early 1920′s, the Manning home was used as a rental property. After the Chattins fled in April of 1925, a Hinton newspaper noted that in May, Mr. and Mrs. L.A. Dodd were moving into the house for the summer. I’m not entirely sure they stayed long, however. While I couldn’t find any news articles about the Dodds fleeing in terror from the haunted house, I’m not sure they would have wanted to stay around for what happened at the house in June. 

On June 12, 1925, Talcott Unit A of the Summers County Klan no. 90 held a huge event. Klan members were to meet at the nearby school and parade to a stage area set up near the Manning home for “patriotic speaking and drill performance.” The public was invited to witness the spectacle and were to assemble on the grounds of the Manning property. An estimated 2500 people showed up! Whether the Dodds were Klan supporters or not, I don’t think they’d have been too happy with 2500 people plus an actual cross burning on their lawn, which makes me think the house was once again abandoned. Unfortunately, Mrs. Chattin wasn’t the only white-clad figure causing terror in Talcott that Spring. However, give me a furniture spinning ghost over the Klan any day. 

The two-story frame home wouldn’t last forever. On December 14, 1951, the house was entirely destroyed by fire. At the time, it was owned by W.D. Lowry. Ashby Lowry was living on the second floor, while the first floor was occupied by Mr. and Mrs. L.B. Rogers. Despite the Lowry ownership, the home was still being referred to as the Manning property. 

The fire started in the second-floor kitchen and quickly spread, causing considerable insurance damage, thanks to Mr. Lowry having recently bought all new furniture and clothing. It is said that hundreds of people blocked traffic for miles on Rt. 3 to watch the old landmark burn. 

So, who was the dresser-turning ghost? The article states that several people had died in the home, and that’s certainly true of most houses of that period. M.A. Manning was probably the most well-known death to have happened in the home prior to the haunting. Was HE the resident ghost, looking after the interior design choices of his former residence? And did the haunting stop with the Chattins, or did other families experience furniture moving around on its own? Since the only activity that was reported was the moving of furniture, it’s possible that this truly was a poltergeist of the recurrent spontaneous psychokinesis (RSKP) variety. Perhaps a young bride, adjusting to married life and the prospects of starting a family made Mabel Chattin the perfect agent for poltergeist activity.

Whatever the cause or whomever the culprit, parallels between this case and another are evident. In February of 1925, the Stokes family was run out of a haunted house in Hinton when doors flew open and beds shook in the night. You can read about that story on my post Terror on Temple Street! 

The Hinton Daily News 11 April 1925

The Hinton Daily News 13 June 1925

Beckley Post-Herald 15 December 1951

Source: http://theresashauntedhistoryofthetri-state.blogspot.com/2025/07/terror-in-talcott-poltergeists-and-klan.html