Fwd: Weekly Commentary: Smotrich's Annexation - Hundreds of Thousands of Arab Residents -Good Move

–Apple-Mail-B75955CE-97B0-4E3D-B270-4A1706FED161
Content-Type: text/plain;
charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Begin forwarded message:

From: imra@imra.org.il
Date: 4 September 2025 at 16:48:50 GMT+3
To: Aaron Lerner
Subject: Weekly Commentary: Smotrich’s Annexation – Hundreds of Thousands of=
Arab Residents -Good Move
Reply-To: imra@netvision.net.il

=EF=BB=BFWeekly Commentary: Smotrich’s Annexation – Hundreds of Thousands of=
Arab Residents -Good Move
Dr. Aaron Lerner 4 September 2025

First some basics:

Ordinance Law and Administration, 1948
…
11B The law, jurisdiction and administration of the State shall apply to any=
area of the Land of Israel that the Government sets in an order.

So the Cabinet meets and votes and its over.

Whatever territory is marked on the map as designated for annexation would b=
e annexed in a single cabinet vote.

And that vote could take place without it even being on the agenda for the m=
eeting if no minister objects so it could be done literally with absolutely n=
o advance warning.

There is a rich history of court cases establishing that a “resident” of Isr=
ael is someone whose “center of life” is in Israel. =20

So the moment that the Cabinet votes to annex an area, any Arab who was livi=
ng in that area at the moment whose “center of life” is that location would b=
e a resident of Israel.

Here is a link to 1.13.0001 issued by the Population and Immigration Authori=
ty with guidelines for establishing if Israel is someone’s “center of life”.=

https://www.gov.il/BlobFolder/policy/policy_determining_center_of_life/he/1.=
13.0001.pdf

So all the Arabs present in the annexed area at the time of annexation who p=
ermanently resided in the annexed area would be Israeli residents.

That would give them the right to live anywhere in Israel and also the right=
to all of our social welfare services as well as all the tax obligations.

They could also get a laissez passer for travelling overseas.

They also would qualify to apply for Israeli citizenship so that they could p=
articipate in the national elections either as a voter or a candidate.

What does Minister Smotrich’s annexation map include?

The map annexes all but some tightly delineated major cities.

I say “tightly delineated” because we annex many industrial areas which are=
adjacent to cities.

For example, it would appear from the map that the fantastic modern factorie=
s in the Hebron area become Israeli factories.

Bethlehem is also annexed, which is great news for Christians and for touris=
m in general.

Kalkiliya, which is a stone’s throw from Kfar Sava and borders on our vital R=
oute 6 toll road is also annexed.

Minister Smotrich indeed set a goal of maximum territory with minimum popula=
tion.

But that “minimum” is hundreds of thousands of people who might shake their=
fists in public over the move while quietly celebrating their good fortune b=
ehind closed doors.

Celebrating the opportunity for a great life – while we celebrate that we ha=
ve the space in Israel for our projected 20 million in 2065.

This is indeed a bold move.

And the right move for our future.

Just as we managed when we added a substantial Arab population when we annex=
ed eastern Jerusalem so too can do this today.
________________________________________
IMRA – Independent Media Review and Analysis

Since 1992 providing news and analysis on the Middle East with a focus on Ar=
ab-Israeli relations

Website: www.imra.org.il

For free regular subscription:
Subscribe at no charge: imra-subscribe@imra.org.il
Unsubscribe: imra-unsubscribe@imra.org.il

For free daily digest subscription:
Subscribe at no charge: imra-subscribe-digest@imra.org.il
Unsubscribe: imra-unsubscribe@imra.org.il

IMRA is now also on Twitter
http://twitter.com/IMRA_UPDATES

–Apple-Mail-B75955CE-97B0-4E3D-B270-4A1706FED161
Content-Type: text/html;
charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

utf-8″>

=3D”ltr”>=EF=BB=BFWeekly Commentary: Smotrich’s Annexation – Hundreds o=
f Thousands of Arab Residents -Good Move
Dr. Aaron Lerner 4 S=
eptember 2025

First some basics:
=

Ordinance Law and Administration, 1948
n>…
11B The law, jurisdiction and administration of the St=
ate shall apply to any area of the Land of Israel that the Government sets i=
n an order.

So the Cabinet meets and votes=
and its over.

Whatever territory is marke=
d on the map as designated for annexation would be annexed in a single cabin=
et vote.

And that vote could take place wit=
hout it even being on the agenda for the meeting if no minister objects so i=
t could be done literally with absolutely no advance warning.
n>
There is a rich history of court cases establishing that a=
“resident” of Israel is someone whose “center of life” is in Israel.  =


So the moment that the Cabinet votes to an=
nex an area, any Arab who was living in that area at the moment whose “cente=
r of life” is that location would be a resident of Israel.
/span>
Here is a link to 1.13.0001 issued by the Population and Imm=
igration Authority with guidelines for establishing if Israel is someone’s “=
center of life”.

https://www.gov.il/BlobFol=
der/policy/policy_determining_center_of_life/he/1.13.0001.pdf
n>
So all the Arabs present in the annexed area at the time o=
f annexation who permanently resided in the annexed area would be Israeli re=
sidents.

That would give them the right to l=
ive anywhere in Israel and also the right to all of our social welfare servi=
ces as well as all the tax obligations.

The=
y could also get a laissez passer for travelling overseas.
/span>
They also would qualify to apply for Israeli citizenship so t=
hat they could participate in the national elections either as a voter or a c=
andidate.

What does Minister Smotrich’s ann=
exation map include?

The map annexes all bu=
t some tightly delineated major cities.

I s=
ay “tightly delineated”  because we annex many industrial areas which a=
re adjacent to cities.

For example, it woul=
d appear from the map that the fantastic modern factories in the Hebron area=
become Israeli factories.

Bethlehem is als=
o annexed, which is great news for Christians and for tourism in general. pan>

Kalkiliya, which is a stone’s throw from Kfar=
Sava and borders on our vital Route 6 toll road is also annexed.
=

Minister Smotrich indeed set a goal of maximum territ=
ory with minimum population.

But that “mini=
mum”  is hundreds of thousands of people who might shake their fists in=
public over the move while quietly celebrating their good fortune behind cl=
osed doors.

Celebrating the opportunity for=
a great life – while we celebrate that we have the space in Israel for our p=
rojected 20 million in 2065.

This is indeed=
a bold move.

And the right move for our fu=
ture.

Just as we managed when we added a su=
bstantial Arab population when we annexed eastern Jerusalem so too can do th=
is today.
________________________________________
>IMRA – Independent Media Review and Analysis
br>Since 1992 providing news and analysis on the Middle East with a fo=
cus on Arab-Israeli relations

Website: www.=
imra.org.il

For free regular subscription: /span>
Subscribe at no charge: imra-subscribe@imra.org.il
>Unsubscribe:          &n=
bsp; imra-unsubscribe@imra.org.il

For f=
ree daily digest subscription:
Subscribe at no charge: imra-=
subscribe-digest@imra.org.il
Unsubscribe:    =
        imra-unsubscribe@imra.org.il=


IMRA is now also on Twitter
n>http://twitter.com/IMRA_UPDATES
=

–Apple-Mail-B75955CE-97B0-4E3D-B270-4A1706FED161–

Source: https://www.imra.org.il/story.php?id=74366